Shared vs dedicated proxies is a question about who else uses your IP. A shared proxy is used by several customers at the same time; a dedicated (or private) proxy is assigned to you only for as long as you rent it. That affects price, speed and, most of all, reputation, because a website judges an IP by everything that's come from it, not just your requests. Rotating pools add a third model that changes how much the distinction matters.
Shared Proxies
With a shared proxy, you get access to an IP or a small set of IPs alongside other paying customers. You might all be hitting different sites, or the same one.
- Cheapest per IP, because the cost is split.
- You inherit other users' behaviour. If someone else hammers a site through the same IP, that site may block or challenge it for you too.
- Bandwidth and connection limits may be shared, so speed varies with others' load.
- Fine for low-stakes tasks on targets that aren't strict.
Dedicated Proxies
A dedicated proxy is one IP that only you use during your rental. Usually it's a datacenter or ISP IP, sold per address per month.
- The IP's recent reputation is shaped by your traffic, not a stranger's.
- Stable address: useful for allowlists or for a site you log into regularly.
- Consistent speed, since nobody else is using the bandwidth.
- Costs more per IP, and you're limited to the number of IPs you rent.
- It still has a history from before you, and once it's flagged by a site, it stays flagged until you replace it.
Where Rotating Pools Fit
Rotating residential and mobile services use a third model. You don't get a fixed IP at all; you get access to a very large pool, and each request or sticky session uses one address for a short time. Other customers use the same pool, so in a strict sense the IPs are shared, but the dynamics are different:
- Your traffic is spread over many IPs, so no single address carries much of it.
- If one IP is flagged on your target, the next request uses another.
- Residential and mobile IPs belong to consumer networks, so they start with a better baseline than most dedicated datacenter IPs. See IP reputation.
- You pay for bandwidth instead of per IP, so you can use thousands of IPs on a small budget.
For scraping and most multi-location work, a large rotating pool usually beats a small set of dedicated IPs. For a long-lived login that the platform expects from one address, a dedicated IP is more natural.
How to Choose
- Do you need the exact same IP for days or weeks (allowlists, a server that only accepts one address)? Dedicated.
- Do you need many different IPs, or many countries? A rotating pool.
- Is the target strict about datacenter traffic? Rotating residential or mobile, whatever the sharing model. See datacenter vs residential proxies.
- Is it a low-stakes target and budget is everything? Shared datacenter, or a cheap datacenter pool billed per GB.
Testing Whether a Proxy Is Already Burned
Whatever you buy, test it against your real target before relying on it. A quick check of status codes over a few requests tells you more than any label:
for i in $(seq 1 10); do
curl -s -o /dev/null -w "%{http_code}\n" \
-x http://USERNAME-country-us:[email protected]:8080 \
https://www.example.com/
done | sort | uniq -cMostly 200s means the IPs are usable on that target. Many 403s or 429s point to reputation or rate limits; see 403 Forbidden with proxies and 429 Too Many Requests.
Speed and Bandwidth
Dedicated datacenter IPs are usually the fastest option because nothing else shares the link. Shared datacenter proxies can slow down at busy times. Residential pools vary by exit, since each one runs over a real home connection, so measure throughput on your own workload rather than trusting a headline figure.
What NodeProxies Offers
NodeProxies plans are pool-based: you connect to one gateway and receive IPs from the residential, mobile or datacenter pool, billed per GB, with sticky sessions when you need an IP to stay put for a while. We don't sell fixed dedicated IPs. If a cheap, private-feeling setup is what you're after, read our cheap private proxies page and the pricing table, then create an account to test.
FAQ
Are dedicated proxies worth it?
When you need one stable IP whose reputation only you affect, yes. When you need many IPs or residential addresses, a rotating pool gives more for the money.
Is a private proxy the same as a dedicated proxy?
Usually yes. Both mean an IP assigned to one customer at a time, though some sellers use private loosely, so check the details.
Are residential proxies shared?
Residential pools are shared among customers, but each request uses one IP briefly and the pool is large, so you rarely feel another user's impact.
Why is my dedicated proxy blocked on day one?
The IP may carry history from earlier renters, or the whole datacenter range may be filtered. Ask for a replacement or switch to residential.
